Corey's Catsup and Mustard CLOSED

This place is now closed

I ate here and I totally recommend the Tomato Soup. While was not the cheapest bowl of soup I have ever had, it was probably the best. Overall, it was great. It does not look like much from the outside, but definitely worth the stop.

This isn't JUST about the beef - although having beef and turkey burger ground an hour before you eat it makes for part of the wonderful flavor at Catsup & Mustard - it's about designing flavor profiles for all sorts of people. The pretzel bun is amazing & worth trying on anything they have and the house-made brisket will make you come back again and again!!

Best burger I've ever had and the fries were outstanding!! Excellent service too!!!

If u want a real hamburger.. u have to try Louis lunch in New Haven... No thrills no toppings... Cuz they want u to taste the beef... 5 different choice cuts to be exact and broiled in seasoned cast iron broilers... Talk about flavor town A true orginal... Been around since 1895... Must be doing something right.. its all about the beef.... Haha where the beef?.

blackened tuna wrap!!!!! sweet potato fries!!! maple mayo is to die for!!! i put it on everything.

For a place that only allows you to order "pink" or "no pink" you'd think they'd be able to get it right, but they don't. Ditto on the overcooked, under-seasoned burgers falling apart, and falling flat on the flavor. Corey's C&M is better than Plan B ANY day of the week. BTW - it's "tasteless" and "imitators"... your spelling is about as good as your taste in burgers. 

Someone told me this Catsup and Mustard was on an episode of Diners drive-ins and dives. It this true?

yumm!

plan b might grind yheir meat twice daily, but they don't season their burgers well and its impossible to get a pink burger there. Also their burgers usually crumble when you eat them. Try goldburgers coreys, or max burger for good burgers.

Blueslider you rock.  No body is better than Plan B...there may be lots of immitators but there is only one place that grinds their meat fresh twice daily.

if you like bland burgers & tastless fixings, this is the place for you. i'll be at plan b

Awesome burger.  I got the bacon blue cheese burger.  An exposion of flavors.  I also got the parmesan garlic fries that were very good.  A great place to eat

The BEST burger I have ever had!  "Oh Burger, You Devil"  PERFECT!