"Tony Boffas in Middletown, NY"
Tony Boffas in Middletown NY!!! Shut the front door it is hands down the very best eggplant parmigiana I've ever had! It's out of bounds! 😉 (Yes, I'm stealing all your lines!) They call it stuffed eggplant and it has the smoothest creamiest ricotta cheese inside it that I wish I knew how to get mine so creamy! Same with their lasagna. The portion sizes in this place are insane! My husband gets the chicken parm and it overlaps the plate rim! It's definitely what you'd call a dive, doesn't look like it's been touched since the owners family started it 60 years ago but oh. My. God. the food is ridiculously amazing. You could definitely eat yourself sick because you just want to keep having more! From the bread that's oiled and herbed to the arancini and fried ravioli apps to the desserts, it's all amazing! I'm a HUGE fan of your show, my brother is your long lost twin, and if you decide to go please call me and we will be sure to be there! My Instagram is @stylebysusanlynn and my cell is 201.819.6738. (Im just a new customer, only recently found the place but I will absolutely be a regular! I can't express to you enough how good it is. I'm definitely a foodie and have visited quite a few of the places you've featured on Triple D!)